| 1861-1863 | Isaac M. Westfall |
| 1866-1868 | Silas Wakefield |
| 1868-1869 | H. S. Hayward |
| 1869 | Eliza M. Tupper |
| 1869-1870 | J. W. Keyes |
| 1871-1873 | Eliza Tupper Wilkes |
| 1874-1881 | George H. Deere |
| 1881-1886 | J. M. Payson |
| 1887-1891 | W. H. McGlauflin |
| 1892-1897 | L. D. Boynton |
| 1898-1901 | L. Ward Brigham |
| 1902-1904 | O. C. Evans |
| 1904-1909 | George F. Patterson |
| 1909-1912 | R. D. Van Tassel |
| 1912-1919 | Noel Edward Spicer |
| 1919-1921 | John Bisbee |
| 1921-1924 | Earnest M. W. Smith later E. M. Whitesmith) |
| 1926-1927 | Owen Whitman Eames |
| 1927-1936 | R. Homer Gleason |
| 1936-1940 | Edward Archer Day |
| 1940-1948 | Horton R. Colbert |
| 1949-1959 | George M. LaPoint |
| 1959-1972 | Vernon L. Curry |
| 1973-1983 | Alexander (Scotty) Meek Jr. |
| 1983-1985 | Warren Turner (interim) |
| 1985-1990 | Fred F. Campbell |
| 1990-1992 | John Gilbert (Beloeved Interim Minister Emeritus) |
| 1992-2005 | Dillman Baker Sorrells (Minister Emerita) |
| 2005-2006 | Sue Turner (interim) |
| 2006 - present | Carol Hepokoski |